TheUnexpectedGuest wrote on July 31, 2022 in GermanTTTNews forum
Hello,
the backhand has always been my problem and I've actually been looking for the right rubber for years (decades). Up until last season I had very good results with a played Sriver because I was able to push and block relatively safely - but also quite harmlessly, which is why I dared to take the step of dealing with short pimples for the first time.
I started testing with a Speedy Soft. Unfortunately, I have little control with it and after 2 training sessions I decided to try the Degu (1.8; wood TSP Fusion Off). This works quite well now, especially when my opponent hits fast topspins, I can block with quite a bit of pressure - accepting serves (my biggest shortcoming) also works quite well.
The only (but unfortunately big) problem are opposing topspins, which come relatively slowly (or high). So I really don't know what to do with it. The blocks either go into the net or back much too harmlessly for the opponent. Are there any tips on what to do here or would other short pimples be even better suited here?
Thanks in advance.
TuG
Wrong question. You don't use short pimples as a weakside rubber.
Short pimples has a very limited scope. Though theoretically the best rubber in tabletennis, short pips is used by just one top shakehand player even on the strong side (forehand ) (Mattias Falck). That should tell you something.
Short pips may also be useful as a strong side (forehand usually) rubber for some older players who either
1. have some physical limitations due to age & can no longer loop
2. picked up the sport at a later age (not youth) and never learned to loop.
There are lots of penholders mostly in China who start playing from a young age using short pips & they may be good at that style but that is a different story. Point is hort pips is not a viable forehand rubber for a shakehander based on statistacal probabilities based on above historical data.
And it goes without saying that short pips is far worse for a shakehander as a weakside rubber.
Short pimples is the worst rubber of all 5 rubber types for a player's weakside (usually backhand for 95% to 99% humans in any racket sport)
Why ? Click here for more details
So unless you are a backhand looper, the only functionally useful weakside (backhand) rubber in the current 40+ plastic ball ONLY era is the high aspect ratio super long pips It is not anti, it is not medium pips and it is not ant long pips listed on ITTF LARC . This applies to you whether you are a close to the table block & smash type player on yoru weakside or if you are an away from the table chopper. You should find the appropriate high aspect ratio super long pips , blockig style or chopping style
Good luck to you
Re:Short pimples on the backhand - block?
Most discussion forums (especially table tennis) are full of posters asking the wrong question based on totally false premises or lack of knowledge about the issue at hand etc. This sub-forum is dedicated to identifying such questions & useless & usually hilarious answers in various tableetnnis forums & also shows what the right answer should have been
Return to “Right Answers to the wrong question”
Jump to
- Americas - North
- ↳ ITTF Americas
- ↳ USA
- ↳ MidWest
- ↳ Illinois
- ↳ Indiana
- ↳ Iowa
- ↳ Kentucky
- ↳ Michigan
- ↳ Minnesota
- ↳ Nebraska
- ↳ North Dakota
- ↳ Ohio
- ↳ South Dakota
- ↳ Wisconsin
- ↳ NorthEast
- ↳ Connecticut
- ↳ District of Columbia
- ↳ Delaware
- ↳ MAssachusetts
- ↳ Maryland
- ↳ Maine
- ↳ New Hampshire
- ↳ New Jersey
- ↳ New York
- ↳ Pennsylvania
- ↳ Rhode Island
- ↳ Virginia
- ↳ Vermont
- ↳ West Virginia
- ↳ Pacific
- ↳ Alaska
- ↳ Arizona
- ↳ California
- ↳ Hawaii
- ↳ Idaho
- ↳ Montana
- ↳ Nevada
- ↳ Oregon
- ↳ Utah
- ↳ Washington
- ↳ Wyoming
- ↳ SouthEast
- ↳ Alabama
- ↳ Florida
- ↳ Georgia
- ↳ Mississippi
- ↳ North Carolina
- ↳ Puerto Rico
- ↳ South Carolina
- ↳ Tennessee
- ↳ SouthWest
- ↳ Arkansas
- ↳ Colorado
- ↳ Kansas
- ↳ Louisiana
- ↳ Missouri
- ↳ New Mexico
- ↳ Oklahoma
- ↳ Texas
- ↳ Canada
- ↳ Alberta
- ↳ British Columbia
- ↳ Manitoba
- ↳ New Brunswick
- ↳ Newfoundland and Labrador
- ↳ Northwest Territories
- ↳ Nova Scotia
- ↳ Nunavut
- ↳ Ontario
- ↳ Prince Edward Island
- ↳ Quebec
- ↳ Saskatchewan
- ↳ Yukon
- iocTT : General & Advanced Discussions ( Non continent specific )
- ↳ For advanced (and above) tabletennis athletes
- ↳ Youth (Juniors, Cadets etc)
- ↳ PTT (Para Table Tennis) and Neuro-Cognitive (Alzheimers, Parkinsons, Dementia) etc
- ↳ Websites of manufacturers & dealers
- ↳ Discussions & help for casual, beginner & intermediate players
- ↳ Masters (Veterans,Seniors, Esquire etc)
- ↳ For Sale (or Free) or Wanted
- ↳ (AI:Artificial Ignorance & NS: Natural Stupidity)> Posts banned (or topics stolen) in ITTF Worship Forums
- ↳ Classic Table Tennis
- ↳ Table Tennis Related Equipment
- ↳ Professional tabletennis players using wrong rubbers, blades, underwear etc
- ↳ Corruption Tracker > IOC, ITTF and its national affiliates
- ↳ Right Answers to the wrong question
- ↳ Other TableTennis Discussion forums
- ↳ So you think you are a TT expert ? Take this quiz
- ↳ Please only use Super Functional Rubbers (not listed on ITTF LARC) as much as possible
- ↳ Choppers - The most ignorant fools of tabletennis
- Americas - South
- ↳ ITTF Americas
- ↳ Argentina
- ↳ Bolivia
- ↳ Bonaire
- ↳ Brazil
- ↳ Bouvet_Island
- ↳ Chile
- ↳ Colombia
- ↳ Ecuador
- ↳ Falkland_Islands
- ↳ Guyana
- ↳ Paraguay
- ↳ Peru
- ↳ Suriname (Dutch Guyana)
- ↳ South Georgia & South Sandwich Islands
- ↳ Uruguay
- ↳ Venezuela
- Americas - Caribbean
- ↳ ITTF - Americas
- ↳ Puerto Rico
- ↳ Janaica
- ↳ Trinidad and Tobago
- ↳ Anguilla
- ↳ Antigua and Barbuda
- ↳ Aruba (Dutch)
- ↳ Bahamas
- ↳ Barbados
- ↳ Bermuda
- ↳ Bonaire (Dutch)
- ↳ British Virgin Islands
- ↳ Cayman Islands
- ↳ Cuba
- ↳ Curacao
- ↳ Dominican Republic
- ↳ Dominica
- ↳ Grenada
- ↳ Haiti
- ↳ Montserrat
- ↳ Saint Kitts & Nevis
- ↳ Saint Barthélemy
- ↳ Saint Lucia
- ↳ Saint Martin - French
- ↳ Saint Vincent & the Grenadines
- ↳ Sint Eustatius & Saba (Dutch)
- ↳ Sint Maarten- Dutch
- ↳ Turks & Caicos Islands
- ↳ United States Virgin Islands
- Africa
- ↳ ITTF Africa
- ↳ Egypt
- ↳ Nigeria
- ↳ Algeria
- ↳ Ivory Coast (Côte_d'Ivoire)
- ↳ Angola
- ↳ Benin
- ↳ Botswana
- ↳ British Indian Ocean Territory
- ↳ Burkina Faso
- ↳ Burundi
- ↳ Cabo Verde (Cape Verde)
- ↳ Cameroon
- ↳ Central African Republic
- ↳ Chad
- ↳ Comoros
- ↳ Congo - Republic of
- ↳ Congo - Democratic Republic
- ↳ Djibouti
- ↳ Equatorial Guinea
- ↳ Eritrea
- ↳ Eswatini [Swaziland]
- ↳ Ethiopia
- ↳ French Southern Territories
- ↳ Gabon
- ↳ Gambia
- ↳ Ghana
- ↳ Guinea
- ↳ Guineaissau
- ↳ Kenya
- ↳ Lesotho
- ↳ Liberia
- ↳ Libya
- ↳ Madagascar
- ↳ Malawi
- ↳ Mali
- ↳ Mauritania
- ↳ Mauritius
- ↳ Mayotte
- ↳ Morocco
- ↳ Mozambique
- ↳ Namibia
- ↳ Niger
- ↳ Rwanda
- ↳ Saint_Helena [Saint Helena Ascension and ristan+da_Cunha]
- ↳ Sao+Tome & Principe
- ↳ Senegal
- ↳ Seychelles
- ↳ Sierra_Leone
- ↳ Somalia
- ↳ South Africa
- ↳ South Sudan
- ↳ Sudan
- ↳ Tanzania
- ↳ Togo
- ↳ Tunisia
- ↳ Uganda
- ↳ Western Sahara
- ↳ Zambia
- ↳ Zimbabwe
- Oceania
- ↳ ITTF Oceania
- ↳ American Samoa
- ↳ Australia
- ↳ Canberra ( Australian Capital Territory )
- ↳ New South Wales
- ↳ Northern Territory
- ↳ Queensland
- ↳ South Australia
- ↳ Tasmania
- ↳ Victoria
- ↳ Western Australia
- ↳ Christmas Island (External territory )
- ↳ Cocos (Keeling) Islands (External territory )
- ↳ Norfolk Island (External territory )
- ↳ AAT (Australian Antarctic Territory)
- ↳ Cook Islands
- ↳ Fiji
- ↳ Guam
- ↳ Heard Island & McDonald Islands
- ↳ Kiribati
- ↳ Marshall Islands
- ↳ Micronesia (Federated States of)
- ↳ Nauru
- ↳ New Caledonia
- ↳ New Zealand
- ↳ Niue
- ↳ Northern Mariana Islands
- ↳ Papua New Guinea
- ↳ Palau
- ↳ Pitcairn Islands
- ↳ Samoa
- ↳ Solomon Islands
- ↳ Tahiti (French Polynesia)
- ↳ Tokelau
- ↳ Tonga
- ↳ Tuvalu
- ↳ Vanuatu
- ↳ Wallis and Futuna Islands
- ↳ United States Minor Outlying Islands
- Americas - Central
- ↳ IITF Americas
- ↳ Mexico
- ↳ Belize
- ↳ Costa Rica
- ↳ EL Salvador
- ↳ Guatemala
- ↳ Honduras
- ↳ Nicaragua
- ↳ Panama
- Europe
- ↳ ETTU (European Table Tennis Union)
- ↳ Åland Islands (Finland)
- ↳ Albania
- ↳ Andorra
- ↳ Austria
- ↳ Belgium
- ↳ Belarus
- ↳ Bosnia & Herzegovina
- ↳ Bulgaria
- ↳ Croatia
- ↳ Czechia
- ↳ Cyprus
- ↳ Denmark
- ↳ England
- ↳ Estonia
- ↳ Faroe Islands
- ↳ Finland
- ↳ France
- ↳ Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes
- ↳ Bourgogne-Franche-Comté
- ↳ Brittany
- ↳ Centre-Val de Loire[2]
- ↳ Corsica
- ↳ Grand Est
- ↳ Hauts-de-France
- ↳ Île-de-France
- ↳ Normandy
- ↳ Nouvelle-Aquitaine
- ↳ Occitanie
- ↳ Pays de la Loire
- ↳ Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur (PACA)
- ↳ French_Guiana (Overseas department)
- ↳ Guadeloupe (Overseas department)
- ↳ Martinique (Overseas department)
- ↳ Mayotte (Overseas department)
- ↳ Réunion (Overseas department)
- ↳ Germany
- ↳ Baden-Württemberg
- ↳ Bavaria ( Bayern )
- ↳ Berlin
- ↳ Brandenburg
- ↳ Brandenburg
- ↳ Bremen
- ↳ Hamburg
- ↳ Hesse ( Hessen )
- ↳ Lower Saxony ( Niedersachsen )
- ↳ Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania ( Mecklenburg-Vorpommern )
- ↳ North Rhine-Westphalia (Nordrhein-Westfalen NRW )
- ↳ Rhineland-Palatinate ( Rheinland-Pfalz
- ↳ Saarland
- ↳ Saxony ( Sachsen )
- ↳ Saxony-Anhalt
- ↳ Schleswig-Holstein
- ↳ Thüringen
- ↳ Gibraltar
- ↳ Greece
- ↳ Greenland
- ↳ Guernsey
- ↳ Hungary
- ↳ Holy See [Vatican City]
- ↳ Iceland
- ↳ Ireland
- ↳ Isle of Man
- ↳ Italy
- ↳ Latvia
- ↳ Jersey
- ↳ Liechtenstein
- ↳ Luxembourg
- ↳ Lithuania
- ↳ Malta
- ↳ Moldova
- ↳ Monaco
- ↳ Montenegro
- ↳ Netherlands
- ↳ Drenthe
- ↳ Flevoland
- ↳ Friesland ( Fryslân )
- ↳ Gelderland
- ↳ Groningen
- ↳ Limburg
- ↳ Noord-Brabant ( North Brabant )
- ↳ Noord-Holland ( North Holland )
- ↳ Overijssel
- ↳ Utrecht
- ↳ Zeeland
- ↳ Zuid-Holland ( South Holland )
- ↳ Northern Ireland
- ↳ North Macedonia
- ↳ Norway
- ↳ Poland
- ↳ Portugal
- ↳ Romania
- ↳ Russia
- ↳ San Marino
- ↳ Serbia
- ↳ Slovakia
- ↳ Slovenia
- ↳ Spain
- ↳ Svalbard and Jan Mayen Islands
- ↳ Sweden
- ↳ Switzerland
- ↳ Türkiye
- ↳ Ukraine
- ↳ Wales
- Asia
- ↳ ATTU (Asian Table Tennis Union)
- ↳ Afghanistan
- ↳ Armenia
- ↳ Bahrain
- ↳ Azerbaijan
- ↳ Bangladesh
- ↳ Bhutan
- ↳ Brunei Darussalam
- ↳ Cambodia
- ↳ China PRC
- ↳ Beijing
- ↳ Tianjin
- ↳ Shanghai
- ↳ Chongqing
- ↳ Nèi Měnggǔ Zìzhìqū
- ↳ Guǎngxī Zhuàngzú Zìzhìqū
- ↳ Xīzàng Zìzhìqū
- ↳ Níngxià Huízú Zìzhìqū
- ↳ Xīnjiāng Wéiwú'ěr Zìzhìqū
- ↳ Guangdong
- ↳ Henan
- ↳ Shandong
- ↳ Sichuan
- ↳ Jiangsu
- ↳ Hebei
- ↳ Hunan
- ↳ Anhui
- ↳ Hubei
- ↳ Zhejiang
- ↳ Yunnan
- ↳ Jiangxi
- ↳ Liaoning
- ↳ Fujian
- ↳ Shaanxi
- ↳ Heilongjiang
- ↳ Shanxi
- ↳ Guizhou
- ↳ Jilin
- ↳ Gansu
- ↳ Hainan
- ↳ Qinghai
- ↳ China, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region
- ↳ China, Macao Special Administrative Region
- ↳ Chinese Taipei (Taiwan)
- ↳ Georgia
- ↳ India
- ↳ Andhra Pradesh
- ↳ Andaman & Nicobar (UT)
- ↳ Arunachal Pradesh
- ↳ Assam
- ↳ Bihar
- ↳ Chandigarh (UT)
- ↳ Chhattisgarh
- ↳ Dadra & Nagar Haveli and Daman & Diu (UT)
- ↳ Delhi (NCT UT)
- ↳ Goa
- ↳ Gujarat
- ↳ Haryana
- ↳ Himachal Pradesh
- ↳ Jammu & Kashmir (UT)
- ↳ Jharkhand
- ↳ Karnataka
- ↳ Kerala
- ↳ Ladakh (UT)
- ↳ Lakshadweep (UT)
- ↳ Madhya Pradesh
- ↳ Maharashtra
- ↳ Manipur
- ↳ Meghalaya
- ↳ Mizoram
- ↳ Nagaland
- ↳ Odisha
- ↳ Puducherry (UT)
- ↳ Punjab
- ↳ Rajasthan
- ↳ Sikkim
- ↳ Tamil Nadu
- ↳ Telangana
- ↳ Tripura
- ↳ Uttar Pradesh
- ↳ Uttarakhand
- ↳ West Bengal
- ↳ Indonesia
- ↳ Iran
- ↳ Iraq
- ↳ Israel (Part of European Table Tennis Union)
- ↳ Japan
- ↳ Jordan
- ↳ Kazakhstan
- ↳ Korea North
- ↳ Korea South
- ↳ Kuwait
- ↳ Kyrgyzstan
- ↳ Laos
- ↳ Lebanon
- ↳ Malaysia
- ↳ Maldives
- ↳ Mongolia
- ↳ Myanmar [Burma]
- ↳ Nepal
- ↳ Oman
- ↳ Pakistan
- ↳ Palestine
- ↳ Philippines
- ↳ Qatar
- ↳ Saudi Arabia
- ↳ Singapore
- ↳ Sri Lanka
- ↳ Syria
- ↳ Tajikistan
- ↳ Thailand
- ↳ Timor-Leste [East Timor]
- ↳ Turkmenistan
- ↳ United Arab Emirates
- ↳ Uzbekistan
- ↳ Viet Nam
- ↳ Yemen
- Welcome
- ↳ IOCTT > Forum Details
- Off Topic, Forum Issues, Testing, other sports etc
- ↳ Test Posts, Forum Issues / Suggestions, Posting questions, Newbies etc
- ↳ Off-Topic
- ↳ Other sports